With school starting up again (TODAY!)  I have to switch my wardrobe in a massive way.  My Patagonia pieces that were key to my old job have to be more for the weekend and I must opt for more tailored pieces.  Not a problem because I LOVE clothes.  Shocker, I know.  Anyway, I have my eyes on a new pair of brogues.  I would love to add a silver pair to my life but which ones?  Traditional ones like the ones above or sneaker ones like the ones below.

I am not sure I can get away with either of them.  But they have my attention.
Which ones would you pick?